mind & bodyanalysisWellcome Collection

People can come to believe lies they once knew were false, and experiments show it can happen within weeks

the gist

People can come to believe fictions they invented, not only lies told by others. In a 2018 study by Laura Paige, participants filled out a questionnaire, told to lie on half the questions, and later some came to accept the lies as true, especially older adults. A 2008 study by Chobrak and Zaragoza asked people to invent detailed false life events, and after eight weeks nearly half reported them as real, even after they had refuted them earlier. The mechanism is that the memory of a source gets lost while the content stays, so familiar invented details feel like genuine recollections. The case of Tania Head, a woman who falsely claimed to be a 9/11 survivor, is an extreme example, though whether she believed her own story is unknown. The effect has implications for police interviews and false confessions.

how it works

Memories are reconstructed each time they are recalled, so the brain keeps the content of an experience while the tag saying where it came from fades. A story repeated or practised often enough can feel familiar, and familiarity is easily mistaken for remembered experience.

so what

Self-deception helps explain how false information takes hold in private memories, the press and courtrooms. It shows that confidence in a memory is not proof it happened.

Wellcome Collection · CC BY 4.0

Illustrative photo · Susanne Diekelmann, Hans-Peter Landolt, Olaf Lahl, Jan Born…, CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons