mind & bodyanalysisWellcome Collection1896 · France

In 1896 Emile Zola let doctors study him to test whether great writers were mad

the gist

In 1896 the novelist Emile Zola agreed to a year-long psychological study by the young French psychiatrist Edouard Toulouse, who examined his medical history, memory, vocabulary, handwriting and even his fingerprints. The idea behind it was that creative geniuses were touched by madness, a belief rooted in the 19th-century view that artists had highly strung nervous systems. Toulouse concluded that Zola was a neuropath with an unbalanced nervous system, and Zola welcomed the conclusion as confirmation of his sensitivity. Later research did not support the link. Havelock Ellis studied about 1,000 creative geniuses and found only 4 per cent had any mental illness, and Albert Rothenberg's 25-year study found no specific personality type linked to outstanding creativity. The myth persisted partly because Romantic thinkers valued imagination over reason.

so what

The myth of the mad genius still shapes how people think about artists and mental illness, and the evidence against it is more than a century old. Seeing where the idea came from helps separate romantic storytelling from what studies actually show.

fun fact

Louis Wain's paintings of cats became increasingly abstract as his mental illness progressed, a case often cited in the mad genius debate.

more on this

background

Émile Édouard Charles Antoine Zola (also US:; French: [emil zɔla]; 2 April 1840 – 29 September 1902) was a French novelist, journalist, playwright, the best-known practitioner of the literary school of naturalism, and an important contributor to the development of theatrical naturalism. He was a major figure in the political liberalization of France and in the exoneration of the falsely accused and convicted army officer Alfred Dreyfus, which is encapsulated in his renowned newspaper opinion headlined J'Accuse...!  Zola was nominated for the first and second Nobel Prizes in Literature in 1901 and 1902.

From Wikipedia: Émile Zola (CC BY-SA 4.0) ↗

key facts

Born
2 April 1840
Died
29 September 1902
Known as
political reporter, art critic

Facts: Wikidata (CC0)

Wellcome Collection · CC BY 4.0

Illustrative photo · Nadar, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons