politicsanalysisThe Conversation

Why working-class people account for around 1% of lawmakers in the US – and only 2% in the average democracy around the world

the gist

Very few lawmakers in the US or in other democracies have worked in jobs such as construction, restaurant service, trucking or clerical work before entering politics. Researchers estimate that about half of American workers hold working-class jobs, but only about 1% of state legislators and members of Congress came from them. Across 97 democracies, the average national legislature draws only about 2% of its members from working-class jobs. The researchers found that working-class candidates are about as qualified and as likely to win as white-collar candidates. The main barrier is that they rarely run, because campaigning costs time, income and personal security, and party recruiters tend to favour professionals.

how it works

Campaigns demand unpaid time, money and a willingness to face public scrutiny, and an unstable job makes all three harder to give up. Party leaders and interest groups recruit candidates, and they tend to pick people who look like the successful candidates they already know, which filters out many qualified workers before any vote is cast.

so what

Who sits in legislatures shapes which laws get passed, and the researchers link lower representation to weaker safety nets and worker protections. The explanation shifts the question from voter preference to who is recruited and who can afford to run.

has this happened before?

Political scientists have documented for decades that legislatures in many democracies are dominated by lawyers, business people and other professionals. The working-class gap is one part of this wider pattern of uneven representation.

Illustrative photo · Mostafameraji, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons