historyanalysisWellcome Collection17th century · England
Psychologists have retrospectively diagnosed Martin Luther with OCD, but the evidence is shaky
Historians and psychologists sometimes diagnose famous figures from the past using modern categories such as obsessive compulsive disorder. OCD involves intrusive, unwanted thoughts that cause distress, followed by compulsions that offer only temporary relief. In 1691 an English bishop described a similar pattern in people tormented by religious doubt, which he called religious melancholy. Psychologist Erik Erikson applied the OCD label to the Reformer Martin Luther in 1958, but much of his evidence came from Luther's associate Philipp Melanchthon rather than Luther himself. Critics argue that the religious and moral context of such suffering was different, and that its meaning cannot be mapped neatly onto a modern diagnosis.
Retrospective diagnosis says as much about the diagnosers and their era as about the people diagnosed. Without the subject's own words, a modern label can flatten what their suffering actually meant to them.
Wellcome Collection · CC BY 4.0
Illustrative photo · M.Bitton, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
