historyWikipedialate 15th century · Europe
Columbus was not doubted for thinking the Earth was flat, but for underestimating its size
A common story says medieval Europeans were held back from sailing west by belief in a flat Earth, and that Columbus proved the world was round. Historians say the real debate was about distance. Educated people already knew the Earth was round, and the dispute was over how far it was to Asia. Columbus grossly underestimated the planet's circumference because of two calculation errors, which made the East Indies seem closer than they were. Scholars who rejected his plan were right about the distance, and Columbus was lucky that the Americas stood in the way. The flat-Earth version was popularised in the nineteenth century, notably by Washington Irving's biography of Columbus.
It corrects a widely repeated myth and shows how a biography can shape what generations believe about science and history. It also shows that a bold voyage can rest on a mistake.
The idea that medieval Europeans broadly believed in a flat Earth is itself largely a later myth.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia · text CC BY-SA 4.0
Illustrative photo · Sebastiano del Piombo, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
