arts, ideas & societyanalysisWikipedia1996 · New York, USA

A physicist submitted deliberate nonsense to a humanities journal, and it was published

the gist

In 1996 physicist Alan Sokal submitted a paper to the cultural-studies journal Social Text titled "Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity". It was deliberately nonsense, proposing that quantum gravity is a social and linguistic construct, written to sound good and flatter the editors' ideological preconceptions. The journal, which did not use outside peer review by scientists, published it. Three weeks later Sokal revealed the hoax in Lingua Franca. The affair sparked a debate about rigour in the humanities, postmodernism, and the ethics of the deception.

so what

The hoax became a landmark of the "science wars", with supporters saying it exposed sloppy standards and critics arguing it was a deceptive stunt that proved little about a whole field.

fun fact

Sokal later wrote a book, Beyond the Hoax, in 2008, reflecting on its implications.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia · text CC BY-SA 4.0