
arts, ideas & societyThe Public Domain Review1897 · New York City, USA
In 1897 a New York newspaper's reply to an eight-year-old about Santa became the most reprinted editorial in English
In 1897 eight-year-old Virginia O'Hanlon asked whether Santa Claus was real, after classmates said he was not. Her father suggested she write to The Sun, a major New York newspaper, which promised that if it appeared there, it was true. The editor Francis Pharcellus Church replied with an unsigned editorial arguing that the most real things are often the ones we cannot see, such as love, generosity and imagination. The reply became the most reprinted editorial ever published in an English-language newspaper.
The answer became a cultural touchstone, reprinted for generations and adapted into books, a film and a television series. It shows how a newspaper of the period used its authority to speak to the public in a warm, philosophical register rather than in news reporting. It also captures a late nineteenth-century mood, when many Americans felt doubt about certainty after the Civil War.
Image: The Public Domain Review
