
historyThe Public Domain Review1860s · Wakefield, England
Charles Darwin studied asylum patient photographs to understand human emotion
In the late 1860s Charles Darwin began collecting photographs of people with mental illness, many sent by the neurologist James Crichton-Browne, who directed the West Riding Lunatic Asylum in Wakefield. Darwin wanted images of facial expressions for his theory that emotional displays were shaped by evolution, and he found that photographs of actors posing were often unreliable. Patients who could not conform to social norms seemed to show more authentic emotion, so the images were valuable to him. The correspondence between the two men lasted nearly six years and covered topics such as blushing and the bristling of hair. The studies fed into The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals (1872), widely regarded as the first English-language scientific book to use photographs.
The book helped establish that human emotional expressions have evolutionary roots shared with other animals. It also shows how early scientists relied on photography as a supposedly objective record, while still carrying the era's prejudices about mental illness.
Darwin's photograph collection also included cross-dressed actors, smiling sculptures and collages of dogs.
Image: The Public Domain Review
