mind & bodyanalysisThe Conversation

‘Must I take all my antibiotics?’ Why infectious disease experts are rethinking this longstanding rule

the gist

For decades doctors told patients to finish every antibiotic pill, partly because stopping early was thought to breed resistant bacteria. The evidence does not support that idea: relapses after short courses usually come from reinfection or from drug not reaching the infection, not from resistant bacteria. Strep throat, for example, has never developed penicillin resistance even after decades of use. Antibiotic resistance is driven by exposure itself, since each extra day of treatment disrupts gut and other bacteria and gives resistant strains an advantage. Trials across bladder infections, pneumonia and bloodstream infections have shown that shorter courses often work as well as longer ones. The best approach is the shortest course proven to cure a specific infection, with the length set by a clinician.

how it works

Antibiotics kill susceptible bacteria, but they also reduce the bacteria living in the gut and elsewhere. Resistant bacteria that survive gain room to grow, so each additional day of treatment increases the selection pressure. A shorter course reduces that pressure while still clearing the infection, if the dose is enough and the drug reaches the infected tissue.

so what

Because antibiotic resistance is driven by overuse, the key message shifts from finishing every pill to avoiding unnecessary prescriptions. A 2025 review of 412 studies found that about a third of antibiotic prescriptions worldwide are inappropriate. Clear communication is needed so that changing the advice does not erode trust in public health.

Illustrative photo · CDC, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons