odditiesanalysisThe Conversation (US)1842 · New York City, USA

A Feejee Mermaid on display in Colorado may shock and intrigue – but it’s no longer considered a ‘missing link’ on the evolutionary tree

the gist

The Feejee Mermaid was a hoax that fooled 19th-century America. In 1842 showman P.T. Barnum displayed in New York a withered creature billed as a mermaid caught near the Fiji Islands, with a monkey-like upper half joined to a fish tail. It was actually a type of folk art made in Japan and the East Indies, where such fish-and-monkey hybrids were sold as charms and linked to the ningyo, a mermaid-like yokai that could curse or grant long life. A sailor bought one, and Boston museum owner Moses Kimball sold the idea to Barnum, who planted newspaper letters from a fake expert before exhibiting it. Some viewers took it as a missing link between sea and land life, and it fuelled debate about evolution.

so what

The mermaid shows how easily a good story and fake expertise could pass for science, and how Barnum used publicity to turn doubt into ticket sales. Today it is displayed as a cultural artefact, not a specimen.

fun fact

Barnum's American Museum burned down in 1865, and Kimball's Boston museum later kept a Feejee Mermaid of its own.

The Conversation

Illustrative photo · Daderot, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons