historyanalysisThe Public Domain Review1855 · Sevastopol, Crimea

A famous 1855 Crimean War photograph was probably staged, and rocks gave it away

the gist

Roger Fenton took two photographs of the same Crimean valley in 1855, one with cannonballs in the ditch and one with them scattered across the road. The road version became the famous image, and historians long argued that Fenton had moved the cannonballs for effect. Errol Morris later found the answer in five small rocks on the slope, which sit lower in the road picture. They had been knocked downhill when people walked around staging the scene, which means the road image was taken second. The photo is one of the earliest examples of a staged war photograph.

how it works

Early photographic plates needed long exposures, so photographers could only capture stationary objects and posed people. Fenton's equipment was large and slow, which made it hard to record the chaos of battle directly. Small changes in the scene, such as rocks shifting down a slope, can therefore reveal the order in which the two pictures were taken.

so what

The case shows how early photography was closer to painting than to reportage, because long exposures could only capture still scenes. It also shows how historians can test a famous image against physical evidence.

Image: The Public Domain Review