odditiesLibrary of Congress: Headlines & Heroes1921 · Cape Hatteras, North Carolina, USA
The Mysterious Disappearance of Ghost Ship Carroll A. Deering’s Crew
In January 1921, the five-masted schooner Carroll A. Deering was spotted off North Carolina's Cape Hatteras with its sails set but no crew. When the Coast Guard boarded it after it ran aground on the Diamond Shoals, food had been prepared and was untouched, and the lifeboats were gone. The twelve men aboard had been heading from Barbados to Norfolk, Virginia. Theories ranged from mutiny to pirates and Bolshevik plots, but a Coast Guard captain argued the crew most likely took the lifeboats to try to reach shore in 90 mph winds and huge waves, and that no lifeboat could survive those seas. The mystery was partly fuelled by a message in a bottle that was later shown to be a hoax by the man who claimed to have found it.
The case shows how easily a mystery can be built from missing evidence and newspaper speculation. Newspapers of the time linked it to other vanished ships, including the USS Cyclops, and the Bermuda Triangle myth only came decades later. The most plausible explanation is the grim one, which is why the story remains a classic of maritime disappearances.
A message found in a bottle, which seemed to point to pirate capture, was faked by the man who claimed to have found it.
background
Carroll A. Deering was an American five-masted commercial schooner launched in 1919 and found run aground without its crew off Cape Hatteras, North Carolina, in January 1921.
From Wikipedia: Carroll A. Deering (CC BY-SA 4.0) ↗Library of Congress (Headlines & Heroes)
Illustrative photo · Daily Arkansas Gazette, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
