historyanalysisThe Public Domain Review1860s–1870s · Germany

Copying Pictures, Evidencing Evolution

the gist

Ernst Haeckel's embryo drawings, published in the 1860s and 70s, showed vertebrate embryos such as fish, chick, turtle and human looking strikingly alike early in development. He argued this similarity reflected common descent, and the grids became one of the most widely seen images in biology textbooks. Critics accused him of drawing the embryos too similar, and he admitted that some woodblocks were reused for different species. Modern biologists reject the drawings as inaccurate, though the broader evidence for evolution from molecular homologies is strong.

so what

Haeckel's images show how a single diagram can outlive its accuracy and keep teaching for decades. The controversy also shows why scientists debate what counts as fraud versus simplification.

Image: The Public Domain Review