historyanalysisNLM Circulating Now1924 · Chicago, USA

What Makes a Murderer: Dr. Bernard Glueck’s Psychological Evaluations

the gist

In 1924 two wealthy Chicago teenagers, Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb, murdered a neighborhood boy for the thrill of getting away with it, and their lives were saved partly by a psychiatrist's report. Bernard Glueck, a leading criminal psychiatrist, evaluated both men for their lawyer Clarence Darrow, arguing that they were psychologically damaged rather than simply evil. The reports traced their crime to feelings of inferiority and to fantasies that had taken over their judgment. Because they had already pleaded guilty, insanity could not be formally used, but the psychiatric evidence helped the court spare them from execution, and they received life sentences.

so what

The case showed how early twentieth-century courts were beginning to weigh psychological explanations when deciding punishment, a shift that still shapes debates about responsibility and sentencing. Glueck's archive at the National Library of Medicine preserves how forensic psychiatry was practised before modern diagnostic standards existed.

more on this

background

Nathan Freudenthal Leopold Jr. (November 19, 1904 – August 29, 1971) and Richard Albert Loeb (June 11, 1905 – January 28, 1936), together known as Leopold and Loeb, were two American murderers who kidnapped and killed 14-year-old Bobby Franks in Chicago, Illinois, United States, on May 21, 1924.

Leopold and Loeb, both of whom were students at the University of Chicago, were respectively ages 19 and 18 years, and were engaged in a same-sex relationship at the time of their crime. They committed the murder hoping to demonstrate their superior intellect, which they believed enabled and entitled them to carry out a "perfect crime" without consequences. The murder and subsequent trial received intense and sensational coverage in the press.

From Wikipedia: Leopold and Loeb (CC BY-SA 4.0) ↗ · text CC BY-SA 4.0

U.S. National Library of Medicine

Illustrative photo · Unknown author, CC BY-SA 3.0 de, via Wikimedia Commons